Andrew Marr

Walking the tightrope between cynicism and sincerity

2016-03-16T13:45:20+00:00March 16th, 2016|Featured|

Life is either always a tightrope or a feather bed. Give me the tightrope. Edith Wharton I wrote recently about unscrupulous optimism. Mostly this seems to have been understood as a warning against the unbridled enthusiasm for the new and the recklessly blinkered belief that the best possible case will always come to pass. Naturally enough I suppose, some readers read into it a celebration of negativity and cynicism. This could not be further from the truth. My favourite definition of cynicism comes from the novelist John Fowles who wrote in The Magus, "All cynicism masks a failure to cope - an impotence, in short, and [...]

The revolutionary wisdom of the tribe

2017-04-11T23:16:27+01:00March 12th, 2016|blogging|

In A History of the World, Andrew Marr suggests there needs to be a balance between new ideas and what he calls 'the wisdom of the tribe': What is the right balance between state authority and individual liberty? No successful state is a steady state. All successful states experience a relentless tug-of-war between conservatism, the wisdom of the tribe, and radicalism, or new thinking. The wisdom of the tribe really matters: it is the accumulated lessons of history, the mistakes as well as the answers, that a polity has gathered up so far. But if this wisdom is not challenged, it ossifies. The [...]

Go to Top